‘Tearing others down is never a good look’ – Donal Skehan responds to Samantha Mumba calling Eurosong panel ‘rude and vile’
Chef Donal Skehan has responded to criticism by Samantha Mumba about the Late Late Show Eurosong panel, who she said were “unnecessarily rude and vile to all the finalists” during the competition to select Ireland’s next Eurovision entry.
In a lengthy post, Skehan, who participated in the Eurosong in 2008, said “tearing others down is never a good look” as he defended his role on the panel alongside 2FM presenter Laura Fox and Dancing with the Stars judge Arthur Gourounlian.
He said that it was “completely unprofessional” for Mumba to “insult the credentials” of the panellists as he said her song “simply wasn’t strong enough” and the comments made by the panel were “never personal”.
Mumba performed her single My Way on Friday night. While she scored high in the jury votes, she was not selected to represent Ireland in Switzerland this May.
Norwegian singer EMMY won with her song Laika Party, a tribute to the Russian dog that was the first living creature to be launched into Earth’s orbit in 1957.
EMMY’s act received 34 points, while Mumba’s song came in second with 26.
On Instagram on Sunday evening, Mumba thanked the creative team who collaborated with her on My Way, before questioning the qualifications of the Eurosong panel – aside from last year’s Eurovision representative Bambie Thug – who she praised.
She said the rest of the panel did not “have the credentials, experience or professionalism required” to take on that role and “were unnecessarily rude and vile to all the finalists”.
She said she would have spoken to them about the feedback and told them how she felt “but they all left the green room before I had the opportunity to”.
In a social media post this afternoon, Skehan said he wanted to recognise the “passion, effort, and dedication that every artist brought to the stage” and acknowledged that Mumba’s response is “personal and comes from a place of deep emotion, something that is entirely understandable in such a high-stakes competition”.
“However, tearing others down is never a good look, especially when everyone involved has worked to make the process as fair and constructive as possible,” he said.
“To insult the credentials of myself and my fellow panelists, Laura Fox and Arthur Gourounlian is completely unprofessional.”
Skehan added that each panellist had been chosen for their experience, insights and passion for Eurovision, and took their role “seriously and approached the night with thoughtfulness, integrity and respect for the artists”.
“The reality is that Eurosong is ultimately about the strength of the song. While Samantha delivered a fantastic performance, the song itself simply wasn’t strong enough, a point that was reflected not just by the panel but by the public vote.”
He said it is “important” to directly address the criticisms of his qualifications, adding: “It might be easy to write my off as ‘just a TV chef,’ but my career began in music.
“I’ve had two number one singles in Ireland with my band, Industry, supported acts like JLS and the Pussycat Dolls, and competed in Eurosong myself in 2008.”
Skehan said he has been a “lifelong” Eurovision fan, attended the contest in the 1990s and has watched how it has evolved into a contest that “demands much more than just a good song”.
He added that his comments were not personal, but were focused on what would give Ireland the best chance of Eurovision success.
Skehan encouraged anyone considering entering the Eurosong to study what has worked in the Eurovision and to “come prepared with a song and vision that can stand out on an international stage”.
He added that there is work needed on creating a standalone platform for Eurosong and “feedback and criticism are never easy to give or receive”, but that his goal has “always been to support Ireland’s Eurovision journey”.
“I stand by my role on the panel, and I wish Samantha and all the contestants the very best as they continue their artistic journeys. Representing Ireland is an incredible honour, and I look forward to supporting this year’s entry EMMY with pride.”
The panel consisted of Skehan, Dancing with the Stars judge Arthur Gourounlian – who danced on stage with Sibel at the Eurovision in Athens in 2006, and 2FM broadcaster Laura Fox. Bambie Thug was the only professional singer on the panel.
News in 90 – Monday, February 10
In comments under her post, Mumba referred to Fox, Skehan and Gourounlian as a “trio of absolute bozos”.
She also said her “parting gift” to the panel was “a bag of [emoji] to slowly choke on”. The emoji Mumba used was the aubergine icon.
On the programme, Mumba cited Bambie Thug as being one of the reasons why she had decided to take part in Eurosong.
Mumba also thanked those who has supported her and the entry.
“Thank you so so much for all the incredible messages and love!!” she wrote.
“I’ve tried to respond to them all. I am beyond proud of myself and the team for all the work and dedication we all put into this performance. I honestly wouldn’t change a thing. Truly. Those that got it, GOT IT…..and those that didn’t, that’s ok too. It’s my art and I stand by it.”
Donal Skehan appeared to refer to Mumba’s post when he shared a selfie on Sunday evening with the words ‘Bozo’ written across it, he also included two aubergine emojis.
He chose the 2025 Maltese Eurovision entry – Miriana Conte’s Kant (which means singing) – to accompany the Instagram story.
A spokesperson for RTÉ said in a statement to the Irish Independent: “We are extremely grateful to the Late Late Show Eurosong panel for their professionalism, insight, integrity and good humour.
“Their role is to give their honest reaction to the performances on the night, offering their thoughts on the likely success of the song and act at the Eurovision Song Contest.
“Our panel did this in a thoughtful and considered way. It seems this was in line with the public vote that ultimately made the decision on the artist and song they wished to represent Ireland at this year’s contest. It’s never easy to offer a personal opinion, as not everyone will agree.
“Our panel did that with the utmost care and we wish to extend our thanks to them for the excellent job they did on Friday night.”