Russell Crowe’s haunting transformation into Nazi leader Hermann Göring left TIFF audiences spellbound Sunday night — and perhaps a bit unsettled. The premiere of “Nuremberg” didn’t just earn a standing ovation; it sparked the kind of stunned silence that speaks volumes about cinema’s power to confront humanity’s darkest chapters.
Twenty-odd years after “Gladiator,” Crowe hasn’t lost an ounce of his commanding screen presence. If anything, the years have added layers of complexity to his craft that make this possibly his most unnerving performance yet.
“You can’t play a character like this and not walk away… feeling things that maybe shake you,” Crowe admitted on the red carpet, his characteristic Aussie directness softened by what seemed like genuine disquiet. The weight of portraying Hitler’s right-hand man had clearly left its mark.
Based on Jack El-Hai’s “The Nazi and the Psychiatrist,” the film pairs Crowe with Rami Malek in what’s shaping up to be 2025’s most intense psychological showdown. Malek brings a controlled intensity to American psychiatrist Douglas Kelley, tasked with determining whether Nazi prisoners were mentally fit for trial. What unfolds isn’t just a battle of wits — it’s a masterclass in sustained tension.
Director James Vanderbilt took some fascinating creative risks. He withheld archive footage of concentration camp victims from his actors until filming the courtroom scenes, a choice that paid off in raw, gut-punch reactions that’ll likely have Oscar voters reaching for their ballots come awards season.
The stellar ensemble — Michael Shannon, John Slattery, Leo Woodall, and a particularly sharp Richard E. Grant — creates what Deadline’s calling “urgently important” cinema. But let’s be real: this is Crowe’s show through and through.
Crowe’s approach to the role? Well, that’s complicated. “We’re going to have to get together tomorrow morning,” he quipped to festival-goers. “It’ll probably take about two hours to answer that question, so bring some sandwiches and something to drink.” Classic Crowe deflection, but the performance speaks for itself — he went all in, mastering German dialogue and diving deep into the psyche of a man whose ego convinced him he could control history’s narrative.
The November 7 release date isn’t random — it’s strategically positioned ahead of the trials’ 80th anniversary. Sony Pictures Classics clearly sees awards potential, and honestly? They might be onto something.
Behind the scenes, the project nearly flatlined multiple times. “The money dropped out three times,” Crowe revealed, though Vanderbilt’s “magnificent” screenplay (co-written with El-Hai) kept drawing talent back like moths to a particularly dangerous flame.
As Hollywood continues wrestling with how to portray historical atrocities — especially in our current climate of rising extremism — “Nuremberg” seems to have found that sweet spot between unflinching honesty and compelling storytelling. It’s a reminder that some stories need telling, even when — especially when — they make us squirm in our seats.
The film industry’s got a spotty track record with historical dramas (looking at you, 2024’s “Napoleon”), but “Nuremberg” might just raise the bar for what thoughtful, challenging cinema can achieve. Time will tell if audiences are ready for its particular brand of truth-telling.