Brandi Carlile’s latest announcement has sent waves of excitement through the music world, and honestly, who can blame them? The eleven-time Grammy winner is stepping back into the spotlight with “Returning to Myself,” her first solo venture since 2021’s “In These Silent Days.” Set to drop this October 24th, the album promises to be a raw, unflinching exploration of solitude that feels particularly poignant in these post-pandemic years.
The timing couldn’t be more intriguing. Fresh off her soul-stirring performances with Joni Mitchell at Newport ’24 and that goosebump-inducing collaboration with Elton John, Carlile’s choosing to strip things back. Way back. This new project feels different – there’s a vulnerability here that cuts deeper than her recent collaborative work.
Talk about a dream team behind the boards. The production credits read like a who’s who of modern music: Andrew Watt (fresh off his groundbreaking work with Pearl Jam), Aaron Dessner (still riding high from that Taylor Swift renaissance), and Bon Iver’s Justin Vernon. Each brings their signature sound to the table, yet somehow manages to let Carlile’s voice remain the north star.
The title track? It’s a gut-punch wrapped in a black-and-white video. Director Floria Sigismondi captures something raw and real as Carlile delivers what might be the most honest lyrics of 2025: “Returning to myself is such a lonely thing to do / But it’s the only thing to do.” Simple words that somehow manage to say everything.
Carlile’s not pulling any punches about the album’s genesis, either. “I’m not my favorite person to spend my time with,” she admits with characteristic candor. There’s something refreshingly human about an artist of her caliber acknowledging the tedium of self-reflection. It’s not all profound revelations and breakthrough moments – sometimes it’s just sitting with yourself, boring as that might be.
The album’s getting a joint release through Interscope and the newly resurrected Lost Highway label (and what a comeback story that’s turning out to be). Carlile cites Emmylou Harris’s “Wrecking Ball” as a touchstone, which makes perfect sense – both albums represent artists taking bold creative leaps while staying true to their roots.
The ten-track collection features some familiar faces. The Hanseroth Twins are back, naturally, along with the remarkable SistaStrings collective. Add in the powerhouse rhythm section of Matt Chamberlain and Chad Smith, plus Josh Klinghoffer’s keyboard wizardry, and you’ve got something special brewing.
Here’s where it gets really interesting, though. Carlile’s wrestling with some heavy questions about the nature of personal growth. Is enlightenment really found in solitude? Or maybe – just maybe – it’s in the messy business of learning to love and live with others? The album doesn’t pretend to have all the answers, but it’s asking all the right questions.
“Returning to Myself” might just be Carlile’s most revealing work yet. Not because she’s figured it all out, but because she’s brave enough to admit she hasn’t. In her words: “Why is it heroic to untether, when the tense work of togetherness is so much more interesting?” Sometimes the bravest thing isn’t walking away – it’s staying put and doing the work.